A Stanford Student Reporter Is Behind An Explosive Investigation Tessier-Lavigne has been under scrutiny for possible misconduct in some of his papers since November 2022, after a campus newspaper, The Stanford Daily, reported that they contained apparently altered images. Renowned scientists joined the investigation into Stanford's president. Supreme Court holds affirmative action unconstitutional, so whats next? Bargmann has been quoted in a number of glowing profiles of Tessier-Lavigne and the two are publicly close. Reporting by The Daily this week shows that some witnesses to an alleged incident of fraud during Tessier-Lavignes time at the biotechnology company Genentech refused to cooperate because investigators would not guarantee them anonymity, even though they were bound by nondisclosure agreements. Scientists contest that assertion. 263 Spotlight Investigations Editor. None of The Dailys sources for its Feb. 17 article has been interviewed by the committee. Now, four former Genentech senior scientists and executives allege that an internal review in 2011 discovered the paper had been based on fabricated research and that Marc Tessier-Lavigne kept the results of the review from becoming public. The matter is now headed for a jury trial in Houston. . The report confirmed many details previously reported by The Daily and broke new ground in other areas. Law Offices of Gary Martin Hays & Associates Find him on Twitter @tab_delete. The Daily's ongoing coverage contains all allegations reported so far and updates that continue to emerge over the president and the multiple bodies investigating his work. Tessier-Lavigne is the lead author on two of these papers. Stanford president's research under investigation Stanford University is circling the wagons around its president after student journalists uncovered serious allegations of scientific misconduct in academic papers he'd published. A federal judge has denied summary judgment to several banks accused in a $4 billion lawsuit of providing banking services that supported the Allen Stanford Ponzi scheme. Last updated at 2:20 p.m. This is perfect for attorneys licensed in multiple jurisdictions or for attorneys that have fulfilled their CLE requirement but need to access resourceful information for their practice areas. Questions regarding these data should be addressed to the lead (corresponding) authors, the University wrote. Three other papers published in Science and Nature by the University president also contain serious problems, according to Elisabeth Bik, a biologist and science misconduct investigator routinely featured in outlets such as The New York Times, The New Yorker and Nature, who was contacted by The Daily last month to review several separate allegations. Aidan Ryan, a senior vice president for crisis communications at Edelman and spokesperson for the committee, would not name the expert the committee was consulting. Theo Baker is the Vol. Q&A: How this Stanford freshman brought down the president of the university. A fourth paper, also published in Science with Tessier-Lavigne as the lead author, appears to show a reused pair of gel bands, according to Bik. Stanford president to resign after investigation into scientific papers Silvia Bulfone-Paus, a prominent German researcher, was forced to step down as the director of the Borstel Institute in 2011 after image manipulation was found in several of her papers (Bulfone-Paus blamed two of her post-doc researchers). ET. | Website designed by nclud, Higher Education News, Opinion and Careers | Weekdays, Quick Summary of the Week's Higher Ed News | Fridays, Admissions and Enrollment News, Opinion and Careers | Mondays, Diversity News, Opinion and Career Advice | Tuesdays, Student Success News, Ideas, Advice and Inspiration | Weekdays, Princeton Professor Objects to Retraction of Economics Paper, Texas A&M Professor Suspended for Allegedly Criticizing Lieutenant Governor, The Stanford Board of Trustees noted in its own statement, raised concerns about student suicide rates. (Photo: HARRY. Big Law's Path to Office Mandates, 'Patently Unreasonable': Twitter Blasts Vijaya Gadde's $1.1M Legal-Fee-Reimbursement Request. Stanford president Marc Tessier-Lavigne to resign after probe on In the report, the scientific panel raised questions about allegations of fraud in a major 2009 Alzheimers study that claimed to have found the cause of neurodegeneration in Alzheimers patients and was publicly called the most important discovery in Alzheimers in the last 20 years, maybe ever by former Genentech executive Richard Scheller. Tessier-Lavigne has denied the charges from the beginning, pushing back forcefully at times on the newspaper, which he accused of making a string of false allegations and unfairly questioning his integrity. A previous version of this article contained copy errors in which an axon was incorrectly referred to as a netrin, The EMBO Journals unabbreviated name was misstated and a screenshot was incorrectly attributed. It was later settled. Copyright 2023 Inside Higher Ed All rights reserved. What distinguishes a university from a knowledge enterprise? Scientists join review of Stanford president's research - The One of them, Simon Kimber, a physicist then at the University of Burgundy Franche . Stanford University Pr esident Marc Tessier-Lavigne announced Wednesday he will step down next month . Four of those people also spoke about a third instance of alleged fraud that they said resulted in another scientist under Tessier-Lavignes lab leaving the company. A president steps down over research-misconduct accusations. News University 'MTL knew': misconduct allegations independently corroborated in private correspondence to special committee The faculty senate at a February 2023 meeting. Prior to taking on Stanfords presidency in early 2016, Tessier-Lavigne directed more than a thousand scientists at biotechnology companies Genentech as well as Regeneron. Four neurobiology papers co-authored by the president, a prominent neurobiologist, are now under review for alleged scientific misconduct regarding altered images and other errors in several scientific journals. 2023 THE STANFORD DAILY PUBLISHING CORPORATION, Privacy Policy Accessibility Advertise, Donate and support The Daily when you shop on Amazon. Meanwhile, professors have publicly questioned his ability to lead as he grapples with mounting allegations. Stanford president to resign after investigation into scientific papers Stanford University President Marc Tessier-Lavigne in a 2009 photo while he was Genentech's chief scientific. Community members have. Critics have also raised concerns about student suicide rates, and the university is currently being sued by the family of former soccer star Katie Meyer, who died by suicide last year. The Stanford investigators were informed of this third alleged incident in a February email obtained by The Daily. Stanford University will investigate its president, a prominent neuroscientist, over allegations that research papers he co-authored years ago might contain altered images. 263 Spotlight Investigations Editor. 2023 THE STANFORD DAILY PUBLISHING CORPORATION, Privacy Policy Accessibility Advertise, Donate and support The Daily when you shop on Amazon. Sources wouldn't participate in probe of Stanford president Theo Baker is the Vol. Of the other two, the University wrote that the issues do not affect the data, results or interpretation of the papers.. Beyond those official consequences, research misconduct can also erode public trust. Stanford University said it will review allegations made in its student newspaper that scientific articles co-authored by its president, Marc Tessier-Lavigne, contained altered images. July 19, 2023 Updated 4 PM PT. However, the board agreed it was best for the university that Tessier-Lavigne resign as president. How a freshman brought down Stanford University's president - Los Public allegations first raised on PubPeer in 2018 have brought the 2008 paper to EMBOs attention. Theo Baker is the Vol. This is one of the papers over which the University claimed Tessier-Lavigne had no direct oversight of figures. I think we need to sit tight and wait. Scheller sits on the board of Maze Therapeutics, a company Gitler co-founded. When asked about the specific allegations and the timeframe of the investigation, Batista wrote, We currently cannot comment more substantively before we have a better assessment of the full situation.. Gitler has also published a paper with Tessier-Lavigne. Its definitely in the public discussion on campus.. The paper under investigation by EMBO is one Bik had voiced concerns about to The Daily in an email last month before the review became public. A freshman from Washington, D.C., he is the youngest ever recipient of a George Polk Award. STANFORD, Calif. Its the one thing everyone knows. West Coast Biotech & Life Sciences Reporter. Tessier-Lavignes defenders include some members of the special committee investigating his work, especially Yang, according to several faculty senators. Both options are priced the same. Facundo Batista, EMBOs editor-in-chief, confirmed the investigation in emails with The Daily, writing that the journal has already evaluated the issues raised on PubPeer and as a consequence is currently engaged in a full due diligence screen.. The investigation took eight months, with one member stepping off after The Daily revealed that he maintained an $18 million investment in a biotech company Tessier-Lavigne cofounded. For example, one of the panels in a figure appeared to have been copied directly and in its entirety from another panel. After the Faculty Senate meeting on Feb. 23 during which Tessier-Lavigne defended his work, saying There was no fraud. Contact tbaker 'at' stanforddaily.com. According to Bik, this paper, which was published in the prestigious journal Science, contains figures with image alteration. Dismissing these as not affecting the data is not very reassuring. Consistent with previous accounts, the professor wrote that researchers at Genentech were having trouble replicating the results from the 2009 Nature paper and chose to begin a review in 2011. Tessier-Lavigne, who became Stanford's president in 2016, has been under investigationby the Stanford Board of Trustees since late November, after The Daily revealed concernsthat several. He will also retract or issue lengthy corrections to five widely cited papers for which he was principal author after a Stanford-sponsored investigation found manipulation of research data., According to Jerry Yang, chair of the Stanford Board of Trustees, Tessier-Lavigne will step down in light of the report and its impact on his ability to lead Stanford. Former Dean of Humanities Richard Saller will serve as interim president. Scientific experts raised concerns about four papers that Tessier-Lavigne a renowned neuroscience and former biotechnology executive co-authored between 2001 to 2008, including two where he was the lead author. Qualkenbush, who also serves as a research integrity officer at Northwestern, stressed the obligation for researchers to ensure that the scientific record is correct. If an error is discovered, she said it is incumbent upon researchers to immediately contact the journal where an article is published and initiate action, though she noted it is up to the publication to decide how to move forward. She did not respond when asked how Tessier-Lavigne was alerted. Tessier-Lavignes condemnations of the student newspapers coverage of his alleged research misconduct also prompted scrutiny from outside observers, who questioned whether the president should make such an aggressive public defense amid an ongoing investigation. (She also serves on the Current Opinion in Neurobiology editorial board with Tessier-Lavigne and Newsome). Schellers wife, Susan McConnell, a biology professor who has co-taught a course with Tessier-Lavigne and helped recruit him to Stanford, declined a request to comment. And, while the committee said that it was consulting an expert in image forensics, some of the worlds foremost experts including Elisabeth Bik, Mike Rossner, Jana Christopher, Matthew Schrag and Davo Vaux have not been contacted or heard of anyone who has. This article has been updated to include comment from The EMBO Journal. You have /5 articles left.Sign up for a free account or log in. Gain access to some of the most knowledgeable and experienced attorneys with our 2 bundle options! The committees findings will have major implications for one of the nations top research powerhouses but also more broadly, because of the underlying issues it raises about the conduct of elite science. 'A very disturbing picture': another retraction imminent for And Gregg Semenza, a Nobel-prize-winning scientist, retracted 17 papers after allegations were made on PubPeer. The consequences of research misconduct or missteps can be far-ranging depending on the circumstances, explained Lauran Qualkenbush, president of the Association of Research Integrity Officers and senior director of research integrity and training at Northwestern University. Stanford University President Marc Tessier-Lavigne in a 2009 photo while he was Genentech's chief scientific officer. Stanford University has launched a formal investigation into its own president, neuroscientist Marc Tessier-Lavigne, PhD, for alleged research misconduct pertaining to five scientific. statnews.com In light of the report and its impact on his ability to lead Stanford, the Board decided to accept President Tessier-Lavignes resignation and agrees with him that it is in the Universitys best interests, Jerry Yang, chair of Stanfords Board of Trustees and a former CEO of Yahoo, said in a Wednesday statement. Stanford to investigate its president over research misconduct claims By David K. Li and Evan Bush. The Stanford Board of Trusteesopened an investigationthe next day, eventually bringing aformer deputy attorney general,a Nobel Laureate, a former Princeton president and a former Harvard provoston board to review Tessier-Lavignes research. Biks suspicions of manipulated imagery were corroborated independently in interviews by The Daily with two other misconduct researchers who reviewed the papers. Adam Fagen N ew findings of altered images in research co-authored by Stanford. Tessier-Lavigne is far from the only president to be toppled by controversy in recent memory. Stanford to investigate university president's research over scientific His lawyer wrote in an emailed statement: We will be providing the Special Committee with a full and corroborated refutation of all the allegations.. Marc Tessier-Lavigne wrote a letter to faculty taking responsibility for research with alleged image alteration bearing his name. Candidates must have t Kent & McBride, P.C. Our Team Account subscription service is for legal teams of four or more attorneys. The same day in 2015 that President Tessier-Lavigne was alerted to the issues, he in turn alerted editors at the two journals about the three papers, Mostofi wrote. . The universitys board of trustees has created a special committee to investigate the allegations and has retained a former federal judge and the law firm Kirkland & Ellis to lead its search for answers. The photoshopping was done intentionally, theres no way around it, said Bik in an interview with The Daily after examining the areas surrounding gel bands for patterns and with forensic tools, though she added the motivation was unclear and could have been something other than falsification. Attacks on public higher education are attacks on American democracy, Philip DiStefano writes. The University disagreed, saying, These mistakes also do not affect results or interpretation. One of the research misconduct experts who reviewed figures for The Daily but spoke on the condition of anonymity in light of the sensitivity of the allegations said in response that Tessier-Lavigne should produce the original materials to support that claim. Neither the University nor Tessier-Lavigne responded to The Dailys request for such evidence. Stanford's Board of Trustees is leading the investigation. College journalist Theo Baker's reporting paved the way for Marc Tessier-Lavigne's resignation. While some had already publicly called on Tessier-Lavigne to step down, this latest development has increased pressure. The university's student newspaper, the Stanford Daily, broke the news of the Stanford University President Marc Tessier-Lavigne resigns after flaws Stanford University has tapped an outsider to run an investigation of alleged research misconduct by president Marc Tessier-Lavigne, saying the review will be conducted "with rigor and. Stanford is investigation allegations of research misconduct against its president, Marc Tessier-Lavigne. The Daily has confirmed that the committee only reached out to Science, the journal where several of the papers identified for investigation last year were published, for documents two weeks ago and has yet to schedule an interview with its editorial staff to confirm Tessier-Lavignes account from last November. Dr Marc Tessier-Lavigne Stanford University has launched a formal investigation into its own president, neuroscientist Marc Tessier-Lavigne, PhD, for alleged And even when they do respond, journal investigations are slow, bureaucratic and often entirely confidential, according to several researchers with knowledge of the retraction process. For questions call 1-877-256-2472 or contact us at [emailprotected], An Inflection Point? A public announcement likely means the paper has been under investigation for some time, said a researcher with direct knowledge of journal investigation processes who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the allegations. Higher Education Panel of scientists has joined research review of Stanford's president A Nobel laureate and former leaders of Harvard and Princeton universities are among the experts helping. What is an authentic teacher and how can you become one? In a different figure, Bik said that a gel band appeared to have been copied and flipped around within the panel. More Than $1B Recouped for Victims in Allen Stanford Ponzi Scheme, SEC Accuses San Diego-Based Fusion Hotel Management of Defrauding Investors of $15M, Cadwalader Saw Partner Profits Soar by 70% as Revenue Grew More Than 30% in 2021, Big Law Works 'Around the Clock' as Clients Navigate SVB Collapse, Because Clients Asked, California Law Firm Moves into Texas With Houston Office, Michael Best Creates AI-Focused C-Suite Role, Texas Benefits Exist For Veterans Starting Businesses, People, Places & Profits, Part I: A Look at the Talent Decisions Across the Full Am Law 200, Law Firm Leadership's Guide to Strategic Implementation of GPT-4, Measuring Diverse Power in Law: A Deep Dive Into the 2023 Diversity Scorecard, Case Study: How a Top 20 Am Law Firm & Non-Profit Leveraged Training to Empower Diverse Associates to Hit the Ground Running, 3 Tips to Get Your Transactional Associates Billing Sooner This Fall, Transactional Intellectual Property / Corporate Lawyer - CT or Remote. Gotta love those student journalists. Stanford updates investigation of president's past research - STAT The concerns Bik says she observed in the EMBO paper range in complexity. Customer Service| He earned $1,555,296 from Stanford in 2021 with an additional $700,000 annually as a board director for Regeneron. Contact tbaker 'at' stanforddaily.com. Nonetheless, based on the available research record and other factors, each of the papers has serious flaws in the presentation of research data; in at least four of the five papers, there was apparent manipulation of research data by others, the report stated. Law.com Compass includes access to our exclusive industry reports, combining the unmatched expertise of our analyst team with ALMs deep bench of proprietary information to provide insights that cant be found anywhere else. But an investigation could carry serious consequences for Tessier-Lavigne even if he is absolved of the alleged manipulation or other direct wrongdoing. Within weeks after the publication of a 2001 article in the journal Science now thought to contain doctored imagery, the report said, a colleague in the field identified an error. Stanford to investigate university president's research over scientific Stanford announced that former U.S. Attorney Carol Lam would lead its investigation, upsetting scientists who criticized the University for investigating itself rather than calling on a third party. We are seeking a lawyer with extensive transactional intellectual property experience to join our corporate practice. Access to additional free ALM publications, 1 free article* across the ALM subscription network every 30 days, Exclusive discounts on ALM events and publications. Another paper, published in Nature in 2003 with Tessier-Lavigne listed as the fourth of 14 authors, contains a series of images characterized as different from each other. Weekly Briefing: Stanford's president steps down over research Meanwhile, frustration has mounted with Tessier-Lavigne among some faculty members. The University and Tessier-Lavigne did not respond to questions regarding specific concerns about the paper. The Daily reached out to Science and Nature, where another of Tessier-Lavignes papers containing alleged data alteration was published, for comment. Bik, though, disagreed with the Universitys assertion that the mistakes do not impact the scientific integrity of the papers. Science and Cell haveissued Editorial Expressions of Concernfor three papers for which Tessier-Lavigne is senior author. Robert Malenka, one co-signatory of the letter, has worked at several institutions alongside Tessier-Lavigne, starting at the University of California, San Francisco in the nineties. The board has indicated that the effort involved hundreds of hours of meetings and witness interviews, with more than 50,000 documents reviewed as part of the in-depth investigation that was distilled into a 95-page report. Stanford President Under Investigation for Alleged Misconduct Tessier-Lavigne has denied this characterization and Genentech has contested the executives and scientists version of events. The University did not respond to questions about this allegation. Instead, the investigation concluded that the allegations of fabrication of data in the 2009 paper are not accurate. Tessier-Lavigne said the report clearly refutes the allegations of fraud and misconduct that were made against me.. Stanford faculty members initially expressed mixed reactions, with some encouraging the president to step down amid questions over his research while others cautioned against a rush to judgment. Elisabeth Bik on Twitter: "Stanford president's research under Transpire and Deloitte Forge Strategic Partnership to Deliver Trial Support Serv World Services Group Employment & Labor Group Publishes European Country-By-Coun Bespoke Capital Consulting Expands Portfolio with Strategic Investment in DFW In Kolacia Law, a Rancho Cucmonga Criminal Defense Law Firm, Explains New Californi A district court judge denied summary judgment to five banks that provided the services essential to Allen Stanford's worldwide Ponzi scheme. One editor of a journal urges President Tessier-Lavigne to step down as more allegations of image alteration in papers co-authored by the neuroscientist emerge and the investigation into his work is, according to experts, marred. Similarly, Tougaloo College president Carmen Walters stepped down in June under pressure from alumni over declining enrollment and employee retention concerns, among other issues. One faculty member, Chair of Radiology Garry Gold, emailed The Daily shortly after to express confidence in Marc Tessier-Lavignes leadership and later wrote that the Board of Trustees setting up an independent investigation into the allegations that have been raised is an example of transparent and responsible leadership.. Since 2011, EMBO has employed a data integrity analyst, who analyzes all papers before publication. Carlo Croce, an Ohio State University professor, was beset with similar allegations in 2017 an official review conducted by the university found earlier this year that he had not manipulated imagery himself, but the professor was disciplined over management problems, and two of his researchers, who were determined to have made the falsifications, were dismissed. Allegations at Stanford shine light on science's messy side - STAT

What To Do In Lake George Village, Legacy Traditional School Maricopa Calendar, Articles S